mercredi 14 novembre 2018

Opinions on Kombucha?

Here's an article on Kombucha, which is either a health food fad, a medical miracle, or dangerous and deadly (the article kind of takes a middle approach).

The warning signs of woo pop up early:

Quote:

In May of 1995, Ruth Patras realized that something was wrong with her 5-week-old daughter, Ciara. Initially happy and healthy, about a month after Ciara was born, the whites of her eyes started to turn yellow. Over the next few days, the color deepened, and her appetite diminished. Patras took Ciara to her pediatrician, who sent the family to Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia. Tests revealed that Ciara had biliary atresias, a rare liver disease in which the ducts that pass bile from the liver to the gallbladder and the first section of the small intestine become blocked. Bile serves two functions in the body, helping to digest fat and carry waste out of the liver. When trapped, the excess bile damages liver cells, eventually leading to liver failure.
As you can probably guess, the mother gave her child Kombucha (which she had heard about on a talk show) and:

Quote:

Ciara’s pediatrician objected, but within a few weeks, bile began to drain from her liver, and in follow-up exams, Ciara’s liver appeared softer and smaller. Patras knew this could be the result of a successful Kasai procedure, but suspected that, somehow, the kombucha was involved. She waited nearly a year before telling Ciara’s pediatrician about it again. When she did, the doctor ordered her to stop giving it to Ciara immediately. “She actually reprimanded me,” Patras told me.

The doctor said that there was no scientific evidence for kombucha’s safety or efficacy, but Patras didn’t need any: Her daughter’s health was proof enough.
The article notes that it is sold today as something of a cure-all; another bad sign:

Quote:

Its ubiquity in post-Portlandia America has been largely powered by the reverberations of the claims that attracted Patras over 20 years ago: that it supports digestion, metabolism, cell integrity, immunity, appetite control, weight control, liver function, and healthy skin and hair — or as artsy labels put it today, by promises that it will “rejuvenate, restore, revitalize, recharge, rebuild, regenerate, replenish, regain, rebalance, renew.”
The reason I ask is because this stuff is now front and center in my local supermarket. I figured what the heck and bought one of the medium-priced bottles (about $3.00). Didn't taste terrible, didn't taste great, kind of a weird texture though. Opinions/experiences?


via International Skeptics Forum https://ift.tt/2FiVZoe

Aucun commentaire:

Enregistrer un commentaire