This picture show various "somethings" and i would like to know whether i classify them correctly in respect to whether they are an organism, alive and which species they belong to:
http://www.medicinenet.com/fetal_dev...ow/article.htm
My take picture
1: 1 organism, which is alive and belongs to species homo sapiens
2: no organism visible
3: at least 1 organism visible, alive, homo sapiens (second organism is probably also there, also alive, also homo sapiens, but not clearly visible)
4: as 3
5: as 3
6: as 3
7: here only 1 organism clearly visible, alive, homo sapiens
8: both pictures as 3
9: as 7
10: as 3
11: 2 organisms visible, alive, homo sapiens
12: as 3
13: 3 organisms, alive, homo sapiens
Before you berate me for asking such stupid question, i know various people who would disagree with all the above except 11 and 13. Unfortunately, i cannot understand their arguments, as they tend to hop from one framework to the next, e.g. suddenly discussing which pictures show persons, which pictures show a "something" thats relevant in respect to human rights charta, which pictures show completely dependent organisms, etc.
So please stick with organism yes/no, alive yes/no and species and clarify any error i might have made, because i fail to see any.
http://www.medicinenet.com/fetal_dev...ow/article.htm
My take picture
1: 1 organism, which is alive and belongs to species homo sapiens
2: no organism visible
3: at least 1 organism visible, alive, homo sapiens (second organism is probably also there, also alive, also homo sapiens, but not clearly visible)
4: as 3
5: as 3
6: as 3
7: here only 1 organism clearly visible, alive, homo sapiens
8: both pictures as 3
9: as 7
10: as 3
11: 2 organisms visible, alive, homo sapiens
12: as 3
13: 3 organisms, alive, homo sapiens
Before you berate me for asking such stupid question, i know various people who would disagree with all the above except 11 and 13. Unfortunately, i cannot understand their arguments, as they tend to hop from one framework to the next, e.g. suddenly discussing which pictures show persons, which pictures show a "something" thats relevant in respect to human rights charta, which pictures show completely dependent organisms, etc.
So please stick with organism yes/no, alive yes/no and species and clarify any error i might have made, because i fail to see any.
via JREF Forum http://forums.randi.org/showthread.php?t=268887&goto=newpost
Aucun commentaire:
Enregistrer un commentaire